Check out our other websites: Babble alt|meat GiftBox Epigroove

Difficulty: Expert Sunday, September 3, 2006

Not Completed Play This Puzzle

CHAT LOG for Sunday, September 3, 2006

12:00 am
a

i'm not in the mood for an expert, waa
12:28 am
coppershep

stuck already...started well
1:08 am
SeedyV

Holy wow that was annoying. Multiple of instances of guessing on this one x_X
1:35 am
sprite

Good, another expert.
1:35 am
raggedyandy3478

how ya doing sprite? havent seen you on here in a while
1:36 am
sprite

I have been here, but it is kinda tough to run into eachother here, lol. We spend too little time. I am doing fairly well. And you?
1:37 am
raggedyandy3478

haha, true, good, except my school just lost in American football 2night
1:38 am
raggedyandy3478

wasnt fun, we had the lead and it slipped right out from under us
1:38 am
sprite

Argh, that's bad. Being so close and then loosing :(
1:54 am
sprite

I think I just hit a brick wall.
2:04 am
raggedyandy3478

im talking to too many people on IMs to get to this
2:04 am
sprite

This one sure needs concentration.
2:05 am
sprite

But it is solvable. Have fun :)
2:05 am
raggedyandy3478

i will, gnight/morn
3:48 am
MrOoijer

wow difficult indeed
3:48 am
Linda

is there any point in starting? or should i just give up now?
3:49 am
MrOoijer

there is always ppoint in starting -- but you will need all the greens
3:49 am
Linda

ok i'll give it a go!
3:51 am
MrOoijer

goof luck with it linda
3:51 am
MrOoijer

:-) good
3:51 am
Linda

thanks
3:51 am
bzikofski

anyone has the script to insert all greens ?
3:52 am
Linda

i wish
3:59 am
Linda

ok, so greens everywhere, so i suppose it's down to guessing...
4:03 am
MrOoijer

Here is the "Green Script"

javascript:for (i=1; i<=9; i++) {for (j=1; j<=9; j++) {if (grid[i][j].value == '') {ClearTinySquares(i,j);}}}for (i=1; i<=9; i++) {for (j=1; j<=9; j++) {if (grid[i][j].value != '') {var tmp_value = grid[i][j].value;for (k=1; k<=9; k++) {for (l=1; l<=9; l++) {if (grid[k][l].value == '') {if ((Math.ceil(i/3) == Math.ceil(k/3) && Math.ceil(j/3) == Math.ceil(l/3)) || i == k || j == l) {grid[k][l]['mini'][tmp_value] = -1;}}}}}}}for (i=1; i<=9; i++) { for (j=1; j<=9; j++) { if (grid[i][j].value == '') { for (k=1; k<=9; k++) { if (grid[i][j]['mini'][k] != -1) grid[i][j]['mini'][k] = 1; }}}}for (i=1; i<=9; i++) {for (j=1; j<=9; j++) {if (grid[i][j].value == '') {for (k=1; k<=9; k++) {if (grid[i][j]['mini'][k] != 1) grid[i][j]['mini'][k] = 0;}}}}PopulatePuzzle(grid);void(0);

Instruct
ions for use: copy the block of text above, paste into the URL window of your web browser and hit return. Voila! Green-number autofill!
4:05 am
MrOoijer

never used it myself though, this is from Krys10
4:07 am
Linda

done! only had to make one guess so not as bad as i thought
4:16 am
bzikofski

thanks MrOoijer, i added this to my profile description
4:27 am
bzikofski

i am unable to solve diagrams with all that greens - useless
5:02 am
Moozey

WOW another expert so soon cool!
5:03 am
peternl

hi all
5:04 am
DeaniDino

hi all
5:27 am
Moozey

phew not too bad then
5:42 am
augurus

Whoo!
5:57 am
rjan_de

2 easy for expert
5:59 am
augurus

It feels more like a high tier hard puzzle. I thought I found the defining characteristics for an expert puzzle. Perhaps I need to broaden the list.
7:19 am
Kukana

Well I think that was pretty difficult, there were at least three x-chains or y-chains or xy-chains (I get a bit confused by the terminology) that had to be spotted, so as to do it without guessing.
9:15 am
sungu

I am not an expert so this puzzle is very difficult I think. I am a beginner
9:18 am
sungu

Do u want me same clues for solving this puzzle, or not?
9:37 am
sungu

I solve:))))
10:13 am
caderoux

Most of the Expert level puzzles here are not completely hintable by Simple Sudoku, but are analyzable by Sudo Cue. This one was fully solvable by Simple Sudoku, but had a large combination of colors, multiple colors, XY-wing, X-Wing etc in combination. Probably deserves the Expert rating. It is actually unusual to find one here which requires X-Wing. Something about the generator used here doesn't make many of those.
10:14 am
hurshy

aw cad, you're so eloquent
10:14 am
hurshy

that's what i love about you
10:15 am
caderoux

thx
10:15 am
hurshy

yw
10:18 am
mab

good morning :)
10:19 am
hurshy

morning mabbity mabber
10:19 am
skizzybiz

well would you look at that -- i actually got to use an x-wing. that's the first time ever that i've explicitly used that strategy
10:19 am
skizzybiz

and good morning!
10:19 am
hurshy

i still haven't the faintest idea what x-wing is
10:20 am
Krys10

I just ran this puzzle through sudoku susser for comparison - it used three XY-Wing, an X-wing, an XYZ-wing, and a forcing chain, along with the usual basic techniques of naked and hidden pairs, intersections, etc. This is also consistent with other expert puzzles we've had. Forcing chains are usually what separates the "hard" from the "expert" puzzles
10:20 am
skizzybiz

do you know how hidden pairs work?
10:20 am
mab

note to self: look up x-wing
10:20 am
hurshy

i probably do, skizzy, but don't know the names of things
10:21 am
Krys10

skizzy - a hidden pair is when a pair of numbers is only possible in two squares (although other possibilities are currently there too). Since those two numbers can only be in those two squares, the other possibilities can be eliminated
10:21 am
skizzybiz

have you read the guides and just have a hard time understanding them? cuz i find them confusing most of the time, too
10:21 am
hurshy

HE knows krys, he's finding out if i know
10:21 am
Krys10

ah, sorry, butting in
10:21 am
skizzybiz

haha, thanks krys10, but i know what they are. i was just going to try to use them as a basis for explaining x-wings
10:22 am
Krys10

go for it! I'm still figuring out x-wings too.
10:22 am
hurshy

well skizzy, i find that mostly since the guides ARE confusing, and since i can generally just use my noodle (and the annoying occasional forcing chain), i haven't really tried that hard to learn those things
10:23 am
skizzybiz

hmmm, i guess conceptually hidden pairs and x-wings aren't the same, but they fall into the same bucket in my head
10:24 am
hurshy

you have buckets in your head? woweeeee
10:24 am
skizzybiz

the idea is that if you have 2 rows, for example, with 1s in the same 2 places...
10:25 am
hurshy

go on
10:26 am
skizzybiz

if the 1 in the top left was correct, then the 1s in the bottom left and top right couldn't, so the 1 in the bottom right would also be correct
10:26 am
hurshy

natch
10:26 am
skizzybiz

conversely, if it was the top right, then it forces the answers for the other 3 in a similar way
10:27 am
mab

there seem to be so many subtleties that are learned just by experience....
10:27 am
skizzybiz

so no matter what, those 1s in those two rows are the only possibilities within those two *columns*, so you can eliminate all other 1s from those two columns
10:27 am
mab

that makes sense
10:28 am
hurshy

i don't think i have a set up like that right now, maybe i need to eliminate a few more greens
10:28 am
hurshy

i sometimes use something that's sort of the opposite of that. if i have pairs that line up, then i know that they can't be (say) 3, 4, 4, 3, because then the sudoku would not have a unique solution
10:29 am
skizzybiz

i had to do what amounted to random guessing, but probably could've been solved more methodically with one of them xyz-lambda-double-backflip-twist moves
10:29 am
hurshy

one of them has to go somewhere else
10:29 am
skizzybiz

only after that did i get to the point where i had an x-wing
10:29 am
hurshy

lol is this sudoku or gymnastics
10:29 am
Krys10

whoops, made a mistake, hafta start over
10:30 am
skizzybiz

yeah, exactly. i made that term up, in case it wasn't obvious, because i find the advanced strategy names pretty incomprehensible
10:30 am
hurshy

methinks based on what i'm hearing and time constraints, i will now employ a silly forcing chain
10:31 am
mab

I give skizzy a 10 for that move, although he might have tacked on a double sowcow.
10:31 am
skizzybiz

silly forcing! i think that should be the name for an advanced strategy
10:31 am
hurshy

i believe it's spelt salchow
10:33 am
mab

I've not needed to use the term until just now; hardly seemed worth looking up...
10:33 am
hurshy

i haven't looked it up but i think i've seen it written out on the tv screen whilst watching figure skating, and i have a semi-photographic memory
10:34 am
mab

no tv
10:34 am
hurshy

i know
10:34 am
skizzybiz

dictionary agrees
10:34 am
skizzybiz

(with hurshy)
10:34 am
hurshy

dictionaries usually do agree with me, and then my husband says, well, they are only descriptive, not prescriptive
10:35 am
skizzybiz

so very true
10:35 am
mab

interestingly, many children have eidetic memory but lose it as they mature. I
10:35 am
hurshy

he's even more linguistically snobbish than me
10:35 am
skizzybiz

looking up eidetic...
10:36 am
mab

i've witnessed it
10:36 am
skizzybiz

relating to or denoting mental images having unusual vividness and detail, as if actually visible.
10:36 am
skizzybiz

i mean, that would make sense, because it's hard to live life that way
10:36 am
hurshy

that makes perfect sense
10:36 am
hurshy

as an infant all you can do is take in all sensory data and you have no way to differentiate what is important and what isn't
10:37 am
hurshy

but then, yes, it's not usually very adaptive to maintain that - it's generally better to know what is important!
10:37 am
Anne

what was expert about this game ? One 50:50 guess on one square and it all fell into place.
10:37 am
hurshy

this forcing chain did not get me anywhere, i must try another
10:38 am
hurshy

that'd be it, anne dear
10:38 am
skizzybiz

i think the "expert" part is that it's supposed to be solvable without 50/50 guesses
10:38 am
Anne

works for me ! lol
10:39 am
mab

i've vestiges of eidetic memory myself. expect most people do.
10:39 am
skizzybiz

well, eidetic memory is just one way of describing PTSD, yes?
10:40 am
hurshy

ooh, interesting point
10:41 am
skizzybiz

that's why i said before that people couldn't really live life that way -- even if they weren't reliving traumatic experiences, it's just too confusing
10:41 am
Krys10

PTSD is about involuntary imagery
10:41 am
hurshy

yes, i was concurring with your skizzypoint
10:42 am
skizzybiz

krys10, maybe the dictionary definition of eidetic wasn't very descriptive, but it seemed to be implying the same sort of thing
10:42 am
hurshy

it does, really, that's a great insight, skizzy
10:43 am
skizzybiz

hmm, i'm not so sure: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eidetic_memory
10:43 am
skizzybiz

eidetic is more of a voluntary thing, "photographic memory"
10:43 am
hurshy

still i bet the connection you saw could be useful
10:43 am
skizzybiz

but i think my observation holds for small children, and it's why you can't really say that they have photographic memory in the same way that some adults do
10:44 am
Krys10

I'd rather have eidetic memory than PTSD
10:44 am
mab

play a few games of concentration with a 5-year-old -- quite illustrative of the concept.
10:44 am
hurshy

my semi-photographic memory seems to be involuntary, i wonder if it is somehow related to my anxiety and depression ;)
10:46 am
hurshy

just one thing makes me forget...
10:47 am
hurshy

red, red wine... stay close to me... don't let me be alone...
10:47 am
Krys10

do the three corners of an XY-wing have to be at a right angle? or do they just have to be buddies in pairs?
10:48 am
Krys10

(i think i found one)
10:48 am
mab

hurshy?
10:49 am
hurshy

ah yes, mab did not listen to music in the 90's
10:50 am
hurshy

it's a song mab, was listening to it, and used it for humorous effect
10:50 am
hurshy

in reality, have never had any alcohol other than dipping wafer in communion wine
10:51 am
hurshy

aha
10:51 am
hurshy

an impossibility at last
10:51 am
mab

ah. i was pretty classical in the 90s, not yet jazz-infuenced. You know beethoven, albinoni, sinatra....
10:52 am
hurshy

well this is... reggae rock? UB40
10:52 am
mab

oh hurshy, wine can be so lovely - so many different tastes.
10:53 am
hurshy

at the risk of sounding like spock - which i wouldn't mind - fascinating, perhaps, but highly unnecessary
10:55 am
hurshy

and done. forcing chains may be unsatisfying, but they sure do work.
10:56 am
mab

the mind must have scope for the imagination, to paraphrase Anne of Green Gables, which requires many strictly unnecessary behaviors.
10:57 am
hurshy

well mab, you've seen how zany i can be WITHOUT imbibing, so i don't know that i want to get any zanier. my imagination is quite fertile as it is.
10:59 am
mab

good point, however, one needn't drink to the point of inebriation, my shabbat kiddush experience notwithstanding.
10:59 am
hurshy

oh, but that reminds me, isn't jewish wine supposed to be awful?
10:59 am
hurshy

that's what frasier and niles said...
11:00 am
mab

not any more. it used to be very sweet, but now one finds very good kosher wines.
11:00 am
hurshy

ah. well... i need to get back to babble now
11:01 am
mab

byeeeeeee. well done on sudoku.
11:09 am
David Mitchell

Aww, I missed hurshy
11:12 am
yul

hello
11:13 am
chebuctonian

hello
11:13 am
David Mitchell

'ello
11:15 am
chebuctonian

this doesn't feel like an expert so far...
11:16 am
yul

good :)
11:32 am
yul

it stopped being easy
11:33 am
moojj

:)
11:33 am
chebuctonian

yup, same here
11:36 am
hurshy

hello david mitchell, i have to go eat lunch but as you were sad to miss me thought i would say hello :)
11:59 am
chebuctonian

finally
12:00 pm
yul

good for you, chebuctorian
12:01 pm
chebuctonian

it only took 5 "guesses" or scenarios on Paint (hah, low-tech crappy tool, but I hate paper)
12:01 pm
hurshy

chebuc - i like to mark my "guesses" aka forcing chains using the red on here
12:02 pm
hurshy

it works nicely
12:02 pm
chebuctonian

it's stupid really, I took some guesses that didn't eliminate any other possibilities... it would have been waaaay smarter to start with one of the corners (with fewer possibilities)
12:02 pm
yul

why do you hate paper? too many paper cuts?
12:02 pm
chebuctonian

hurshy-- hmm, that sounds really smart actually
12:03 pm
hurshy

anyone who's still going, i started a forcing chain in r8c8, and it led me to an impossibility, and then i was able to finish.
12:03 pm
chebuctonian

yul: a techie attitude + too much work to set up the grid... hurshy's solution sounds better
12:03 pm
chebuctonian

hahaha, hurshy - that's exactly the one that let me finish
12:04 pm
yul

you don't have a printer?
12:04 pm
hurshy

i don't have a printer at the moment - mine's broken and they took the dorm one away for the summer :(
12:05 pm
yul

that's bad :(
12:05 pm
chebuctonian

I don't have a printer either... they're not really transportable things
12:05 pm
hurshy

i mean i can send things to other printers on campus but then i have to go get them.
12:06 pm
yul

i can't use red on my mac so i print out puzzles (some times)
12:06 pm
hurshy

macs are so anti-communist
12:07 pm
yul

:)
12:08 pm
yul


my is too new
12:08 pm
hurshy

my is moo stew
12:09 pm
yul

is it? i like moo stew
12:10 pm
hurshy

when my sister says "moo stew" to her dog, it makes the dog lick her (my sister's) lips incessantly. it is gross.
12:10 pm
yul

lol
12:11 pm
hurshy

but, sadly, i must away now. over the river and through the woods....
12:11 pm
yul

good bye
12:11 pm
hurshy

(to grandmother's house i go)
12:13 pm
yul

i wish i had a grandma
12:22 pm
yul

i think hurshy is yoda
12:40 pm
bzikofski

hey there
12:40 pm
yul

hi
12:41 pm
bzikofski

anyone can help me with proper english here? i'm not sure about some phrases and the overall tone of my english in my cover letter.
12:41 pm
bzikofski

here's the suspect sentence: "I would appreciate the opportunity to discuss this post with you at a date that suits you best."
12:42 pm
yul

you joking, bzikovski, i can't spell all together :) as long as you mean well, it's fine :)
12:44 pm
bzikofski

i'm not joking.. i already asked for help here :) .. i think it should be "on a date", shoulnt it ?
12:46 pm
yul

ok, but i can help very little with proper english :)
12:47 pm
bzikofski

aight.. where you from ?
12:48 pm
yul

i live in london but i am russian
12:48 pm
yul

i live in london but i am russian
12:48 pm
yul

i live in london but i am russian

12:48 pm
yul

sorry, return is too sensitive
12:55 pm
yul

'return' is my computer's button
1:04 pm
abstract17fr

yes, he/she talk about a date ...
1:07 pm
yul

...talks about what kind of date?
1:07 pm
yul

...talks about what kind of date?
1:09 pm
yul

oh return return... i better stop chatting all together... good bye everybody
1:09 pm
abstract17fr

talk about a date to discuss the post :))
1:09 pm
abstract17fr

bye yul
1:10 pm
yul

i see... thanks, abstract17fr
1:41 pm
ypsigirl

whine whine this is so hard... I was cruising for while there, then abrupt halt
1:47 pm
ypsigirl

me no expert... me go back to babble... get some clues... finish up there...
4:34 pm
ibroadrunr

aw, man, last time I was working on an expert, a storm knocked the electricity out right near the end...dare i start?
5:12 pm
yul

finally! i had to have a dinner with a beer to finish this one
5:41 pm
hoaf

Sheesh. Last night? No idea how to do the puzzle. Today? 10 minutes (with greenies). Weird.
7:16 pm
helenkeller

go
7:43 pm
eyeman

done
8:01 pm
helenkeller

i've been trying to do this during big brother commercials, among other things & am wondering what's taking me so long - i saw the large E & assumed it was easy - & it's not, it's expert, now i have to actually think :/
8:03 pm
eyeman

you'll get it, helen
8:10 pm
helenkeller

done
8:10 pm
helenkeller

ty eye :)
8:10 pm
eyeman

brava
8:11 pm
helenkeller

still, all in all - this one was much easier than the most recent 'hard' - i couldn't do that one-first time ever! tx eye
8:11 pm
helenkeller

off to babble
8:12 pm
eyeman

have fun - seeya around
8:35 pm
Rosanna

Hello Rosanna here, first time. Love these. I think i'm addicted
9:19 pm
Limer

Ha
9:19 pm
Limer

Nailed that puppy
9:19 pm
Stephanie

Hi
9:20 pm
Limer

Rank me, baby
9:20 pm
Limer

1
9:20 pm
Limer

No green or red
9:20 pm
Limer

Cue theme music.
9:20 pm
Limer

Hey, Stephanie
9:20 pm
Limer

How's Arkansas?
9:22 pm
Stephanie

Great! The weather has finally cooled off some and the humidity is down.
9:55 pm
plurple

Limer ... oh limer.
9:55 pm
plurple

You only took two minutes to reply, Stephanie, but Limer's gone.
9:58 pm
Stephanie

Oh well. I am having a tough time with this grid!
10:11 pm
Stephanie

Finally!!
10:54 pm
ibroadrunr

so, I'm new to ironsudoku. what're people talking about when they say red and green?
11:06 pm
thedave

ibroadrunr - try holding down the shift or alt keys when selecting a square
11:10 pm
ibroadrunr

ah. that's lovely. thanks
11:20 pm
ibroadrunr

yay, done.